Jump To Content

LearnHub



Should technology be used to make LBW decisions? (Discussion)

rkmittal saidMon, 15 Sep 2008 05:58:53 -0000 ( Link )

During the recently concluded One Day and Test Match series between India and Sri Lanka, technology was used to a limited extent in cases where a doubtful LBW (Leg Before Wicket) decision by the onfield umpire was referred by one of the 2 sides(i.e the batting or the fielding) for final decision by the third umpire. However, the number of such referrals that could be made by either side per match/inning was limited. Almost 50% of the decisions made by the onfield umpires were reversed by the third umpire by making use of the technology. Notwithstanding objections from certain quarters, this lends support to the wide concern being raised at various levels in the Cricketing fraternity as to why full fledged use of the technology available to us today not be made with a view to impart more fairness and credibility to the game. We have already been using technology in case of almost all other decisions being made by the field umpires, viz. in cases of run outs, stumping, close/doubtful catches etc. I think that the technology should now cover LBW decisions also to remove the element of unfairness and avoidable uncertainty on account of human error from the game. What are your views in this regard?

Actions
Vote
Current Rating
0
Rate Up
Rate Down
No Votes
  1. chandra_avinash saidSat, 20 Sep 2008 14:45:39 -0000 ( Link )

    ah…finally a cricket debate

    i disagree! i feel that using too much technology ruins the fun in the gentleman’s game it was awesome earlier when it all depended on the umpire – now with more technology in the picture, there is no need for umpires – and God knows, we can’t do without umpires :)

    also, i guess the spirit of the game was the way it was till 20 years ago….it’s all glamour and glitz today…. i wonder where the gentlemanly spirit went?

    Actions
    Vote
    Current Rating
    0
    Rate Up
    Rate Down
    No Votes

    Post Comments

Your Response
Textile is Enabled (View Reference)